This Steve Bell cartoon appeared on the Guardian a few days ago and it’s completely perplexed me. I don’t get what it’s saying.

For me, it’s one of two things…either that we should fear the onset of an ‘Islamic republic’ here in Britain whilst ‘our’ troops are fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq, or that we should fear the jingoism of the Government and certain tabloid newspapers following the death of the first British service woman. If it’s the first, then the message is a particularly dangerous one; if it’s the second, then the satire is deeply embedded.

Sadly, I’m tending to lean to the former explanation given the cartoon’s context. In many Muslim areas around the country, the ‘local’ is being force out of business; KFC is where six Muslims died during riots in Karachi whilst another KFC was firebombed during riots against the publication of cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad; and as for Northern Rock, earlier this year Hizb ut-Tahrir published an article about the failings of the capitalist economic system citing the Northern Rock debacle as evidence as did another Muslim blogger on what is titled, The Zakat Pages. Look more closely at the cartoon and you’ll also see the white convert marching in line with the other ‘fundamentalists’, ‘extremists’, ‘radicals’, ‘Islamists’ or whatever else the Government and other commentators are calling certain Muslims nowadays: a suggestion that ‘you can’t trust any of them’. And of course, there’s the various different colloured burkhas covering the women watching from the sides. Scary stuff…??? On a number of levels, definitely…

Given that I wasn’t entirely sure of what message was being conveyed by the cartoon, I distributed it to various colleagues and asked them what they thought the cartoon was saying. Here are their replies:

“If taken at face value, we have to stop fundamentalist Islam from taking hold here because look what will happen”

“It’s an ironic twist on the tabloid hysteria following the death of the female soldier”

“It’s an indictment on today’s Britain…but Steve Bell normally has a satirical edge”

“It’s a satire on Gordon Brown’s reasons for sending troops to Afghanistan”

“I don’t get it – what’s it supposed to mean?”

“It’s challenging perceptions of who supports the troops remaining in Iraq and being increased in Afghanistan and who will benefit because of this”

“It’s challenging the concept of ‘terrorists’, ‘freedom fighters’ etc and what we think about being encouraged to ‘Support our Troops’ from different perspectives”

“Simple, it’s just saying that you can march on the streets and in public, but you can’t drink in public places any more”

“It’s a comment on way we live in a hypocritical society: that binge drinking bad for your health but you can continue to fill your face with KFC; that overeating and binge drinking is still happening despite the downturn in economy; and that you can’t trust anyone or anything, not even institutions that are trusted like Northern Rock?”

“It could just be a satirical observation that this will never happen”

“It’s not just the ‘normal’ Muslims – it’s the converts also that we should be fearful of”

“The end result of Islam in Britain? Fundamentalists and oppressed women”

“The Government is creating a fear of Muslims just so that the public supports the war – to gloss over the fact that the reality of the war is that it is illegal”

“The UK is NEVER going to get Islamicised – so why are we worried ???”

“It looks like a battle cry…context means everything and with mass communication you cannot control the context that people receive, digest and interpret messages and so the cartoon is likely to be seen as a battle cry to stand up against the growing Islamic army”

I personally don’t agree with many of the interpretatations but they do seem to reinforce the final observation, that we cannot control or even guess how the receiving audience will digest and interpret the message that Steve Bell is trying to convey.

Would be happy to hear your views and what message Steve Bell is (or at least is trying) to get across to his audience…

Advertisements

4 thoughts on ““Don’t let this happen…”: the Islamic republic or the lies of hysteria…???

  1. Chris, much as I usually agree with you on this one, I think it is the latter explanation, that the

    that we should fear the jingoism of the Government and certain tabloid newspapers following the death of the first British service woman.

    I think it is also a bit more than this. We had recently the Channel 4 documentary “Jail to Jihad” – highlighted because it is the latest in a long line of ‘negative’ stories about Muslims. It is the equivalent of a channel in a Muslim country having a documentary titled “The Corrupt West: From Drug Addiction to Prostitution”. A lot of the press, whether rightwing, leftwing, broadsheet or tabloid, still have a distinct discomfort with visible expressions of religiosity.

    Regarding the above cartoon and your highlighting the “white convert”, again, I have an alternative thesis. Many of the inhabitants of north Africa look very European and the chap could easily be from there. When this photo was circulated at MY workplace – the mainly Muslim crowd who looked at the photo were puzzled at best and mildly upset at worst. Mostly, they didn’t know what to think.

    Heres my thesis – its just a bad cartoon that was trying to make a good point but didn’t do it so well. Everyone, even Steve Bell, has a low day.

  2. Happy for you to disagree, no worries…as I say, I didn’t really ‘get it’ and so any alternative explanations/ interpretations/ theories are gratefully received.

    However, you’re soooooooo wrong about the ‘white convert’ – he has ginger hair for God’s sake !!!! Not sure the percentage of North Africans that have ginger hair – maybe you could prove me wrong…???

    And last point, one of the Muslims I work with provided the following response from the list above:

    “It’s a comment on way we live in a hypocritical society: that binge drinking bad for your health but you can continue to fill your face with KFC; that overeating and binge drinking is still happening despite the downturn in economy; and that you can’t trust anyone or anything, not even institutions that are trusted like Northern Rock?”

  3. Chris, Chris, my dear friend Chris. Gingers only come from Europe? How sad that you are stooping to such eurocentric views. May I offer visual evidence of a certian mohammed al yaboubi, of syria but originally of Morocco?

    If one travels across the Muslim world, one sees Muslims of all shapes and colours. You get blondes and ginger-haired folk across asia, and North Africa. People travel and have done for centuries – it is a complex world.

    Here is a another one to get the smart head of yours wrapped around (and now that Turkey are doing so well in the football…). What, physically, is Europe?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s