Theresa May and Coalition Government accused of ‘complacency’ over re-hashing failed New Labour policies


The Home Secretary, Theresa May, today pre-empted the publication of the revised Prevent strategy by criticising universities for their apparent “complacency” in tackling radicalisation and Islamic extremism on campus.

In an interview with the Daily Telegraph, May said:

“I think for too long there’s been complacency around universities. I don’t think they have been sufficiently willing to recognise what can be happening on their campuses and the radicalisation that can take place. I think there is more that universities can do”

For a Government that suggest that “we need a strategy that is effective and properly focused…” to tackle the problem of extremism, it is quite staggering that they have therefore chosen to merely regurgitate a much criticised and widely rejected policy suggestion of the former Higher Education minister, Bill Rammell. Back in 2006, Rammell put forward the idea that academics could “spy” on students they suspect of involvement in Islamic extremism and supporting terrorist violence.

Another example surely of the paucity of ideas that exists at the heart of the Coalition debacle.

Despite the regurgitation of New Labour offcasts, another question needs to be asked of May: what evidence do you have that radicalism and Islamic extremism is actually taking place on campuses across the UK. As she herself puts it:

“…recognise what can be happening on their campuses and the radicalisation that can take place”

What “can be happening” is significantly different to what is or even might be happening. And without evidence, it would seem that May and the Coalition are making simplistic and lazy assumptions rather more so than anything else.

And assumptions they would clearly seem to be given that the evidence being put forward is far from convincing.

First off, May states that more than 30% of people convicted of Al-Qaida associated terrorist offences went to university. What she seems to have overlooked is that around 40% of ALL young people go to university in today’s UK. Consequently, the number of people convicted and who went to university is less than the national average.

Second, it would seem that May overlooked a report by Universities UK which was published earlier this year:

“…the view of experts within government is that the higher education sector doe not currently have a major problem with violent extremism”

If the view of “experts within government” less than four months ago stated that British universisties did not have a major problem with violent extremism, on what basis are the charges being made?

May’s comments are symptomatic of the Prevent agenda: simplistic, sensationalist and unsubstantiated. And don’t forget, this simplistic, sensationalist and unsubstantiated exercise to solve the problem’ has categorically failed at the extortionate cost of millions.

Universities must challenge and ultimately reject the Coalition Government’s paltry attempts to scapegoat campuses as a cover for their own inadequacies and the lack of anything that reflects “a strategy that is effective and properly focused”. Universities have to be where open debates and discussions can take place, where a wide range of different – not prescribed – ideas and arguments can be aired and also challenged.

And because of this, we cannot be complacent in defending academic freedom. Or indeed rejecting the complacency of lazy and incompetent politicians. As the Universities UK report put it:

“Universities are open institutions where academic freedom and freedom of speech are fundamental to their functioning. Views expressed within universities, whether by staff, students or visitors, may sometimes appear to be extreme or even offensive. However, unless views can be expressed they cannot also be challenged”

ADDITIONAL NOTE:

In response to Theresa May’s comments about extremism on British campuses, I was interviewed by Phil Mackie live on the Shelagh Fogarty show on Radio 5 Live. This is available – for a limited time – on BBC iPlayer by clicking here.

About these ads

8 thoughts on “Theresa May and Coalition Government accused of ‘complacency’ over re-hashing failed New Labour policies”

  1. When I hear someone say “there could be people on uni campuses with extreme views” I can’t help but feel its something of a flacid statement. I mean, I could be riding the bus and be sitting next to someone with extreme views – does that mean that Travel West Midlands is being complacent over extremism? Not the best possible analogy but still…

    I also think this re-issuing of Prevent is foolish – I know from my work with interfaith that Prevent has exacerbated existing tensions/problems and has caused tensions to appear where previously there were none.

  2. This was such a limp and poorly thought out piece of scapegoating, and it will only serve to distract from dealing with real extremism elsewhere. Bill Rammell was saying pretty the same thing four years ago and it was nonsense then as it is now.

    I sort of also posted on this, although in a juvenille and mean-spirited manner – so I would like to link to this post here, if you have no objections?

  3. If you’re going to continue your pretentious, muddle-headed blog it might be a good idea to get a proper education first. “Hear, hear” is a contraction of “hear him, hear him” which is a exhortation to listen to wise words, long used as an expression of agreement.

    Instead of producing pseudo-academic bilge like ‘Islamophobia’, it might be worth delving a little more deeply into your own motivations for pursuing this particular career trajectory.

    1. You’re absolutely right…!!! I will immediately quit my job as a psuedo-academic and go back to cleaning toilets with the rest of my illiterate working class brethren. Thank you for enlightening me…!!!
      Btw why don’t you identify yourself with your full name and affiliation so that us thickos can look up to your intelligence with awe…I’d love to be able to blow smoke up your arse (damn, my working class commoner language is creeping back in again…!!!)
      Chris

      1. Some of us managed to grow up in working class families and get an education without using our background as a hackneyed excuse for lazy, ignorant language or behaviour.

        So you come from Bermondsey, do you? Big deal. Let’s all go down the Rose or the Britannia and ask the locals what they think of your work. You know what? They’d see through you in five seconds flat. You are a pretentious bullshitter who has benefited from the decline in academic standards in higher education. I bet you couldn’t believe your luck when you used your political contacts to land a job in a university. Now you can prance around, paid for by the aforementioned hard working punters, spouting crap about Islamophobia and convincing yourself – almost – that you’re the real deal.

        Good luck to you – just don’t complain when, once in a while, someone sees through you.

      2. At least I’m brave enough to put my name to my views and opinions unlike those who attack and criticise under the cover of anonymity…!!!
        And who are my political friends…would love to know.
        So come clean Colm, say who you are or go and read the blog of an educated working class real academic – it’ll be good for your blood pressure!
        Chris

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s